CCTV and Evidence After a Supermarket Accident in Scotland

Sarah Johns has over 8 years of experience evaluating personal injury claims across Scotland. Having reviewed thousands of initial case assessments, Sarah specialises in helping consumers understand the Scottish personal injury claims process and connecting them with specialist, panel-approved solicitors.

Edit Template

Supermarkets are full of cameras. That can be very helpful if you’re hurt in one, because footage may show exactly what happened, how long a hazard was there and whether staff walked past it. The problem is that it doesn’t last long.

This guide explains how to secure CCTV and the other evidence that can make or break a supermarket claim.

Table of Contents

Why CCTV matters

Good footage can show:

  • the hazard before you reached it
  • how long it had been there
  • whether staff or other shoppers passed it
  • whether a warning sign was in place
  • how you fell and what you struck

It’s often the clearest answer to the central question in a supermarket claim: did the store take reasonable care?

How long is CCTV kept?

There’s no single rule. Many stores overwrite footage automatically after a few weeks, and some sooner. Once it’s gone, it can’t be recovered. That’s why the first few days after an accident matter so much.

If staff completed an incident report, they may have saved the footage already. Don’t assume they have. Ask.

How to ask for the footage

At the time: tell the manager you want the CCTV kept and ask them to note that in the incident report.

In writing, as soon as possible: send an email or letter to the store and its head office asking them to preserve all footage of the area, from well before the accident until after it. Give the date, time, store address and a description of yourself and what you were wearing.

A subject access request: under UK data protection law, you have the right to ask for personal data an organisation holds about you, which includes footage in which you can be identified. The store normally has one month to respond. It may blur other people’s faces.

If your claim is being handled for you, the request can be made on your behalf.

If the store won't hand it over

Some stores refuse to release footage until a claim is made, or will only show it to their insurer. In Scotland, once there’s a claim, the pre-action protocol expects relevant documents to be shared. If it gets to court, the pursuer can ask the court to order recovery of documents and footage. In some cases, an order can be sought before a court action is raised, to stop evidence being destroyed.

If a store had a request to keep footage and deleted it anyway, that may be raised in the claim.

Other evidence that helps

CCTV is useful, but it isn’t the only evidence. Many claims succeed without it. Other important records include:

  • your photos, taken on the day, of the hazard, the area and any signs
  • witness details, names and phone numbers of other shoppers or staff
  • the accident book entry or incident report reference
  • cleaning and inspection records, showing when the area was last checked
  • your receipt, or loyalty card and bank records, showing the time you were there
  • medical records from A&E, your GP or a minor injuries unit
  • your footwear and clothing, kept as they were
  • a diary of your symptoms and the help you’ve needed

If you were taken to Ninewells in Dundee or the Royal Infirmary in Edinburgh straight from the store, your hospital records will help link the injury to the accident.

What the store will look at

The defender will normally gather its own evidence, including its CCTV, staff statements, inspection logs and cleaning schedules. Its insurer will use these to argue it had a reasonable system in place. That’s why it helps to get your own evidence together early, rather than relying on the store’s version.

Make a Claim Today

Our reputation for excellence in personal injury law is unparalleled, having secured over £3 million in compensation for our clients.

We are committed to achieving the best possible outcomes, consistently delivering exceptional results and ensuring our clients receive the justice they deserve.

Writing your own account

Within a day or two, write down what happened while it’s fresh:

  • the date, time and where in the store you were
  • what you were doing and where you were going
  • what you slipped on or tripped over
  • whether there were signs, staff or other shoppers nearby
  • what was said after the accident
  • who you spoke to

Keep it factual. It will help you later if your memory fades or details are disputed.

Medical evidence

Your solatium and other losses can’t be valued without medical evidence. Get checked even if you think the injury is minor, and keep going back if symptoms continue. Gaps in treatment are often used to argue an injury was less serious than you say.

Time limit

You usually have three years from the date of the accident to settle the claim or raise a court action. Evidence such as CCTV, though, may only last a few weeks.

No win, no fee

Many supermarket accident claims in Scotland are handled on a no win, no fee basis under a Success Fee Agreement. If the claim doesn’t succeed, you don’t pay a success fee. If it succeeds, the success fee is capped by law at 20% of the first £100,000, 10% of the next £400,000 and 2.5% of anything above £500,000, with VAT included. In personal injury claims, outlays such as medical reports and court dues are generally met by the provider, except for any after-the-event insurance premium.

FAQs

Can a supermarket refuse to give me CCTV?

It may delay or limit what it shares, but you have data protection rights and the footage can be recovered through the claims process.

As soon as possible, ideally the same day or within a few days.

Yes. Photos, witnesses, records and medical evidence can all prove a claim.

Usually, yes, unless the request is manifestly unfounded or excessive.

It’s best not to. Posts can be misread and used against you.

Talk to us

Need help securing evidence after a supermarket accident? Call us free on 0333 3051 337 and we can act quickly to request footage.

This guide is general information, not legal advice for your circumstances.